Mystic Island 62 Average
Mystic Island Livability #455 ranked city in New Jersey#17,110 ranked city in the USARanks better than 41% of areas
Is This the Right Place for You? Local Insights Report
  • Uncover the key details before you move
  • Use local data to guide a smarter investment
  • Compare neighborhoods side by side
Local Insights Report

What's it like Living in Mystic Island?

Mystic Island is a small-sized city located in the state of New Jersey. The city has a population of 8,603 inhabitants. At 94%, the majority of the Mystic Island population is White; this is followed by 2% Black and 0% Asian. Based on an average age of 55, Mystic Island appears to be well-suited for seniors or retirees as the average age is well above the national average. Something to be aware of when living in Mystic Island are the above average commute times. If you're looking for a short commute to work, this might not be the right area for you. With one way commute time of 40 minutes, this comes in much higher than the national average of 26 minutes.

Living in Mystic Island can be a great experience for anyone moving to the area. Having said that, in the state of New Jersey, there are many incredible places to live, so choose wisely! When searching for a new neighborhood, several factors play a vital role in determining its suitability. Safety should be a top priority, ensuring a secure environment with low crime rates. Proximity to your workplace or school helps minimize commuting time and allows for a better work-life balance. Availability of essential amenities such as parks, coffee shops, restaurants, grocery stores, and healthcare facilities contributes to convenience and well-being. Access to reliable public transportation options facilitates easy commuting and connectivity. Additionally, considering the sense of community and the overall atmosphere that resonates with your lifestyle and preferences fosters a harmonious living experience. To help you find the best places to live in and around Mystic Island, AreaVibes has created a livability score using key metrics like amenities, education, housing and more.

With a livability score of 62 out of 100, Mystic Island is ranked #15,430 in the United States and #438 in New Jersey. For each of the livability categories, we see that Mystic Island ranks very well for crime (B) and housing (A). On a less positive note, Mystic Island does not have favorable ranks for the following: amenities (F), cost of living (D) and education (F). If we take a look at the data, we can find out why.

For home buyers, real estate will be the largest purchase they will ever make and it will also be their most valuable asset. For renters, the monthly rent paid on their Mystic Island apartments will most likely be their largest expense. Based on tangible metrics like home and rental affordability and appreciation rates, housing in this area has received a score that is well above the average of every other US city. A thriving real estate market can also generate strong local economic activity and job creation.

Assuming that Mystic Island meets all of your requirements like low crime rates, good schools and great local amenities, the next most important item to examine is the affordability of real estate in Mystic Island. Everything else becomes a lot less important if it turns out that home prices in Mystic Island are simply unattainable. The median home price for Mystic Island homes is $376,391, which is 32.2% lower than the New Jersey average. If we take a closer look at the affordability of homes in Mystic Island, we’ll see that the home price to income ratio is 5, which is 2% lower than the New Jersey average.

Best Places to Live in and Around Mystic Island

See all the best places to live around Mystic Island

How Do You Rate The Livability In Mystic Island?

1. Select a livability score between 1-100
0
Awful
25
Poor
50
Average
75
Good
100
Great
2. Select any tags that apply to this area
View results

Compare Mystic Island, NJ Livability

City Image
    City Default Image
      vs

      Mystic Island transportation information

      Statistic Mystic Island New Jersey National
      Average one way commute40min31min26min
      Workers who drive to work79.1%71.7%76.4%
      Workers who carpool9.7%8.1%9.3%
      Workers who take public transit3.3%11.2%5.1%
      Workers who bicycle0.0%0.3%0.6%
      Workers who walk0.0%3.0%2.8%
      Working from home7.2%4.1%4.6%
      Source: The Mystic Island, NJ data and statistics displayed above are derived from the United States Census Bureau American Community Survey (ACS) and include 2026 modeled data developed using proprietary methodologies.