Bay Shore 75 Excellent
Bay Shore Livability #266 ranked city in New York#4,209 ranked city in the USARanks better than 85% of areas
Is This the Right Place for You? Local Insights Report
  • Uncover the key details before you move
  • Use local data to guide a smarter investment
  • Compare neighborhoods side by side
Local Insights Report

Pros and Cons of Living in Bay Shore

PROS
  • Commute Commute

    High commute scores indicates that public transit should be easily accessible in this area and the average commute time to work is less than average.

  • Employment Employment

    The combination of higher than average median home income, income per capita and low unemployment rates results in a score that is well above average in the employment category.

  • Housing Housing

    This area has received high scores in the housing category. This could be due to a positive home affordability ratio, high appreciation rates or elevated home values.

  • Health & Safety Health & Safety

    A high score in the health and safety category is a result of good air quality and the accessibility to health facilities such as hospitals, clinics, doctors, pharmacies and fire stations.

CONS
  • Cost Of Living Cost Of Living

    Based on the most recent cost of living data, this area is more expensive to live in. You can expect to pay more for everyday goods and services, housing, groceries and utilities.

  • Ratings Ratings

    AreaVibes conducted surveys and polls with locals who live in the area. The results were not favorable for walkability of amenities, parks, public transit and the overall sense of community in the area.

What's it like Living in Bay Shore?

Bay Shore is a moderately-sized city located in the state of New York. The city has a population of 32,913 inhabitants. Bay Shore has a population density of 6,091 people per square mile. This would be considered well above the national population density level. More than a quarter of the residents of Bay Shore identify themselves as Hispanic or Latino, and 29% of the population speak Spanish as their primary or secondary language. When traveling to work, spending unnecessary time in your vehicle is not ideal and downright frustrating. Across all of America, the average one way commute time is 26 minutes, unfortunately, living in Bay Shore offers up a higher than average one way commute time of 32 minutes.

Living in Bay Shore can be a great experience for anyone moving to the city. Having said that, in the state of New York, there are many desirable places to live, so choose wisely! When searching for a new neighborhood, several factors play a vital role in determining its suitability. Safety should be a top priority, ensuring a secure environment with low crime rates. Proximity to your workplace or school helps minimize commuting time and allows for a better work-life balance. Availability of essential amenities such as parks, coffee shops, restaurants, grocery stores, and healthcare facilities contributes to convenience and well-being. Access to reliable public transportation options facilitates easy commuting and connectivity. Additionally, considering the sense of community and the overall atmosphere that resonates with your lifestyle and preferences fosters a harmonious living experience. To help you find the best places to live in and around Bay Shore, AreaVibes has created a livability score using key metrics like amenities, crime, cost of living, commute, education and more.

Using data and statistics Bay Shore has received a livability score of 72 out of 100. This score is ranked in the 82nd percentile when compared to all other cities. If we dig a little deeper into each category within the livability score, we see that Bay Shore has higher than average grades for the following: employment (A+) and housing (A+). There are some categories that Bay Shore does not rank well for, including: crime (D) and cost of living (F). It might be worth taking a closer look to figure out why.

Finding affordable real estate and housing in Bay Shore can be tricky. Having said that, this area might be the place to get the best of both worlds. Based on factors like home/rental affordability and appreciation rates, this area has received an above average score in the housing category. A healthy real estate market can lead to wealth appreciation for property owners, as rising property values can contribute to homeowners' equity, financial stability and the ability to build long-term wealth.

There are many factors that go into deciding if an area is the right fit for your lifestyle. Certain “must haves” like low crime, great schools and nearby amenities are all at the top of most people's lists. But before even considering if those options are attainable, we'll need to know if the real estate in Bay Shore is actually affordable. The median home price for Bay Shore homes is $652,237, which is 29.5% higher than the New York average. If we take a closer look at the affordability of homes in Bay Shore, we’ll see that the home price to income ratio is 5.1, which is 8.9% lower than the New York average.

Best Places to Live in and Around Bay Shore

See all the best places to live around Bay Shore

How Do You Rate The Livability In Bay Shore?

1. Select a livability score between 1-100
0
Awful
25
Poor
50
Average
75
Good
100
Great
2. Select any tags that apply to this area
View results

Compare Bay Shore, NY Livability

City Image
    City Default Image
      vs

      Bay Shore transportation information

      Statistic Bay Shore New York National
      Average one way commute32min33min26min
      Workers who drive to work68.2%53.0%76.4%
      Workers who carpool12.5%6.7%9.3%
      Workers who take public transit12.3%28.0%5.1%
      Workers who bicycle0.3%0.7%0.6%
      Workers who walk0.8%6.3%2.8%
      Working from home4.4%4.0%4.6%
      Source: The Bay Shore, NY data and statistics displayed above are derived from the United States Census Bureau American Community Survey (ACS) and include 2026 modeled data developed using proprietary methodologies.