The above shows an overview of the real estate market in Bay Shore, NY. Note how the median home price for Bay Shore, NY runs $309,100, which is 8% higher than the average property price for New York. So you’re going to get real estate in Bay Shore, NY that is on-average less affordable than what you’ll find in the rest of New York. As for rent, the median for Bay Shore, NY runs $1,384, which is comparatively 19% higher than the average rent for New York. For Bay Shore, NY, about 58.9% of the population consist of home owners with about 3.1 people living in each property on average. Whether you’re looking for condos or townhomes that are low-maintenance and affordable or sprawling mansions, Bay Shore, NY offers a wide variety of real estate. To find your perfect home in Bay Shore, NY, filter your choice by price, location, and number of beds and baths using the search area above.