Shelter Island, NY Housing Statistics

Get 300+ Local Insights for Any Address in Shelter Island, NY

Get Access to 300+ Local Data Points

C+

378%

Med. Home Val. NAT. AVG.

100%

Rent NAT. AVG.

38%

Owner Occ. NAT. AVG.

Shelter Island Housing Information

Index	Shelter Island	New York	National
Median home price	$1,560,882	$503,498	$326,622
Median rent asked	$0	$1,761	$1,444
Avg. people per household	1.3	2.6	2.6
Owner occupied households	88.0%	53.6%	63.6%
Renter occupied households	12.0%	46.4%	36.4%

See Local Housing Trends Before You Buy!

See home value trends within a small radius
Understand local market conditions near your address
Use detailed data to choose the right home

GET REPORT →

Homes For Sale In Shelter Island, NY

169 N Ferry Rd

Shelter Island, NY

64A N Midway Rd

Shelter Island, NY

6 Great Circle Dr

Shelter Island, NY

11 Prospect Ave

Shelter Island Heights, NY

Housing Quick Facts

The median home price in Shelter Island is 378% higher than the national average.
The median rent asked in Shelter Island is 100% lower than the national average.
The average number of people per household in Shelter Island is 52% lower than the national average.
The number of owner occupied households in Shelter Island is 38% higher than the national average.
The number of renter occupied households in Shelter Island is 67% lower than the national average.

Most Affordable Places to Live in and Around Shelter Island

See all the best places to live around Shelter Island

Compare Shelter Island, NY Housing

Write a review to give others more information about this area.

See all Shelter Island poll results

The best places in New York

Here are the best places to live in New York

These are the largest cities in New York

These are the 10 cheapest cities in New York

Safest Cities In The US

Nearby cities with low home prices

	Population	Home Price	National Avg.
Fishers Island, NY	63	$0	100%
Dering Harbor, NY	0	$0	100%
Flanders, NY	5,277	$584,147	79%
Greenport, NY	2,113	$893,237	173%
Jamesport, NY	1,070	$896,960	175%
Shelter Island, NY	2,020	$1,560,882	378%

Cities with similar population

	Population	Home Price	National Avg.
Waldport, OR	2,020	$386,894	18%
Manahawkin, NJ	2,019	$583,962	79%
Laurel Hollow, NY	2,019	$2,389,587	632%
Whitwell, TN	2,019	$187,097	43%
Mackinaw, IL	2,019	$242,427	26%
Shelter Island, NY	2,020	$1,560,882	378%

Source: The Shelter Island, NY housing data displayed above is derived from the United States Census Bureau American Community Survey (ACS) and include 2026 modeled data developed using proprietary methodologies.