Photo of Shelter Island, NY
( 0 Ratings )

Living in Shelter Island, NY

Shelter Island Area Facts

  • Shelter Island has a Livability Score of 59/100, which is considered below average
  • Shelter Island crime rates are 86% lower than the New York average
  • Cost of living in Shelter Island is 85% higher than the New York average
Area Score
Is This the Right Place for You? Local Insights Report
  • Uncover the key details before you move
  • Use local data to guide a smarter investment
  • Compare neighborhoods side by side
Local Insights Report

Shelter Island Reviews

Write a review about Shelter Island Tell people what you like or don't like about Shelter Island…
Show All Reviews

How Do You Rate The Livability In Shelter Island?

1. Select a livability score between 1-100
0
Awful
25
Poor
50
Average
75
Good
100
Great
2. Select any tags that apply to this area
View results

Compare Shelter Island, NY Livability

City Image
    City Default Image
      vs
      Compare Neighborhoods & Addresses Local Insights Report

      Why stop at city-to-city? With Local Insights, you can compare neighborhoods, zip codes, or even exact addresses. Access 300+ hyperlocal data points—from schools and crime to housing and amenities—to see which area is the better fit.

      Local Insights Report

      F Amenities

      Are there many local amenities in Shelter Island? Well, there are not many amenities close to this location.

      Parks

      Mashomack Preserve
      5th Street Beach Park
      Windmill Beach Park
      Mitchell Park
      Mitchell Park
      John Steinbeck Waterfront Park
      Foster Memorial Town Beach Park
      Marine Park

      Entertainment

      East End Seaport Maritime Museum
      Long Island Train Museam
      watchtower
      Greenport Theatre

      Food & Drink

      The Shipwreck
      Eagle Deli
      Shelter Island Wines and Spirits
      Rhumb Line
      Whiskey Wad Tavern
      One Kourt Studio
      Greenport Harbor Brewing Company
      Greenport Wines & Spirits

      F Commute

      Is public transit available in Shelter Island? Of all people who commute, 0.0% take public transportation in Shelter Island.
      Drive to Work
      57%

      19% lower than the US average

      Take Public Transit
      0%

      5% lower than the US average

      Walk to Work
      0%

      3% lower than the US average

      B Health & Safety

      Is Shelter Island a healthy and safe place to live? Yes, there are some hospitals, police and fire stations.

      Hospitals

      Pharmacies

      Doctors