Shelter Island Heights, NY Crime Rates: Stats & Map

Get 300+ Local Insights for Any Address in Shelter Island Heights, NY

Get Access to 300+ Local Data Points

A+

60%

Total crime NAT. AVG.

57%

Violent crime NAT. AVG.

61%

Property crime NAT. AVG.

Date & Last Updated: This data reflects the 2024 calendar year and was released from the FBI in September, 2025; this is the most current data available.

Shelter Island Heights crime rates are not available from the FBI crime report. The FBI's uniform crime reporting program (UCR), gathers data from more than 18,000 law enforcement agencies. The agencies include city, university, college, county, state, tribal and federal law enforcement agencies. When combined, they represent approximately 309 million American residents, or a 98% coverage rate of large metropolitan areas. This does result in approximately 20 million people who live in areas where the FBI does not provide crime reports. These areas tend to be smaller towns, villages or suburbs. Given that Shelter Island Heights crime stats are not covered by the FBI crime reports, either data from local enforcement agencies is applied or estimates are calculated based on demographic data including, but not limited to: home prices, income per capita, poverty rates, unemployment rates, educational achievement and population density. The Shelter Island Heights crime estimates should be used at your own risk. Please be aware that the data displayed above is estimated and not officially reported by any agency. The Shelter Island Heights crime map can also be used to view a visual display of crimes committed on a block group level.
Statistic	Reported_incidents	_{/100k people}	Shelter Island Heights_{/100k people}	New York_{/100k people}	National_{/100k people}
Total crime	0	n/a (estimate)	848 (estimate)	2,100	2,119
Murder	n/a	n/a	n/a	2.7	5.0
Rape	n/a	n/a	n/a	21.7	37.5
Robbery	n/a	n/a	n/a	96.1	60.6
Assault	n/a	n/a	n/a	259.6	256.1
Violent crime	n/a	n/a (estimate)	154 (estimate)	380	359
Burglary	n/a	n/a	n/a	136.6	229.2
Theft	n/a	n/a	n/a	1,432.8	1,272.1
Vehicle theft	n/a	n/a	n/a	150.2	258.8
Property crime	n/a	n/a (estimate)	695 (estimate)	1,720	1,760

Get Crime Data Within A 1-Mile Radius!

View detailed crime data near your address
Use local crime insights to avoid risky areas
Get hyperlocal crime stats, not city averages

GET REPORT →

* Crime data not available for every address.

Shelter Island Heights crime map

The Shelter Island Heights crime map by CrimeoMeter provides a detailed overview of all crimes in Shelter Island Heights as reported by the local law enforcement agencies. Based on the color coded legend above, the crime map outlines the areas with lower crime compared to the areas with higher crime. The Shelter Island Heights crime heat map offers insight into the total crimes on a block group level. Please note that the red areas on the Shelter Island Heights crime map does not always indicate that it is a dangerous area for its residents. Areas on the heat map could be inflated if they are located in high traffic areas like airports, sports centers or large parks. Other areas on the heat map could see increased crime rates if they are located in major tourist areas like the downtown core.

Compare Shelter Island Heights, NY Crime

Compare Neighborhoods & Addresses

Why stop at city-to-city? With Local Insights, you can compare neighborhoods, zip codes, or even exact addresses. Access 300+ hyperlocal data points—from schools and crime to housing and amenities—to see which area is the better fit.

UNLOCK FULL COMPARISON →

Crime Quick Facts

Shelter Island Heights crime rates are 60% lower than the national average
Violent crimes in Shelter Island Heights are 57% lower than the national average
In Shelter Island Heights you have a 1 in 118 chance of becoming a victim of crime
Shelter Island Heights is safer than 92% of the cities in the United States
Year over year crime in Shelter Island Heights has decreased by 4%

Shelter Island Heights, NY Crime Quiz

Safest Places to Live in and Around Shelter Island Heights

See all the best places to live around Shelter Island Heights

Write a review to give others more information about this area.

See all Shelter Island Heights poll results

The best places in New York

Here are the best places to live in New York

Check out the 10 safest cities in New York

These are the largest cities in New York

Most Dangerous States In The US

Daily Crime In Shelter Island Heights (per 100,000 people)

How Safe is Shelter Island Heights (higher is better)

Chance of Being A Victim of Crime in Shelter Island Heights

The chance of being a victim of violent crime in Shelter Island Heights is 1 in 652

The chance of being a victim of property crime in Shelter Island Heights is 1 in 144

The chance of being a victim of crime in Shelter Island Heights is 1 in 118

Year Over Year Crime In Shelter Island Heights (per 100,000 people)

Shelter Island Heights police department

Item	Shelter Island Heights	New York	National
Law enforcement employees (officers & civilians)	n/a	109,351	558,732
Police officers & civilians /1000 residents	n/a	2.9	3.3

Sex offenders in New York

State	Total offenders	New York_/100K	National_/100K
New York	25,064	137	266

There are a total of 25,064 sex offenders in New York. This yields a total of 137 sex offenders in New York per 100,000 residents which is 48% less than the national average.

Nearby Cities With Low Crime Rates

City	Population	Violent crime_{/100k people}	Property crime_{/100k people}	Total crime_{/100k people}
Madison Center, CT	2,009	21	214	236
Northville, NY	1,607	53	241	295
Sag Harbor, NY	1,959	53	241	295
Shinnecock Hills, NY	1,575	53	241	295
Bridgehampton, NY	1,235	53	241	295
Shelter Island, NY	1,980	53	241	295
East Marion, NY	1,144	53	241	295
Shelter Island Heights, NY	763	154	695	848

Cities with similar population

City	Population	Violent crime_{/100k people}	Property crime_{/100k people}	Total crime_{/100k people}
Gratz, PA	763	290	1,692	1,981
Dover, MN	763	274	1,711	1,985
Paris, PA	763	256	1,495	1,751
Clarence, PA	763	298	1,736	2,034
Hornbeck, LA	763	567	2,502	3,068
Shelter Island Heights, NY	763	154	695	848

Source: The Shelter Island Heights, NY crime data displayed above is derived from the FBI's uniform crime reports for the year of 2024. The crime report encompasses more than 18,000 city and state law enforcement agencies reporting data on property and violent crimes. The uniform crime reports program represents approximately 309 million American residents, which results in 98% coverage of metropolitan statistical areas.