Middle Island, NY Area Guide

Get 300+ Local Insights for Any Address in Middle Island, NY

Get Access to 300+ Local Data Points
Photo of Middle Island, NY
( 4 Ratings )

Living in Middle Island, NY

Ranks better than 62% of areas Follow

Middle Island Area Facts

  • Middle Island has a Livability Score of 62/100, which is considered average
  • Middle Island crime rates are 6% lower than the New York average
  • Cost of living in Middle Island is 6% higher than the New York average
Area Score
Is This the Right Place for You? Local Insights Report
  • Uncover the key details before you move
  • Use local data to guide a smarter investment
  • Compare neighborhoods side by side
Local Insights Report

What do the locals think about Middle Island?

Based on 3 votes from AreaVibes users. Take the poll

Middle Island Reviews

Write a review about Middle Island Tell people what you like or don't like about Middle Island…
Middle Island, New York - My Hometown! User Rating 4.5 rating By Anonymous ( May 28, 2018) I love living in Middle Island, New York! It's a small town but not too far away from the city. You truly have the best of both worlds here! People are just wonderful and down to earth, the economy and cost of living is quite reasonable, the school district is really good too. Th ...Read More ese are just a few things on a list of several that I could go on and on about why it's so great to live here!

We have some really great attractions you would love to visit as well. Cathedral Pines County Park is probably my favorite of all time! It's a park with access to camping, fantastic trails to walk, hike, or even mountain bike on if you should so choose, secluded areas that are perfect for a romantic intimate picnic, or more open areas that are great for grilling and having barbecue on a Sunday afternoon with your family and friends. And the scenery in the park is so beautiful that it's mesmerizing! Read Less
Show All Reviews

How Do You Rate The Livability In Middle Island?

1. Select a livability score between 1-100
0
Awful25
Poor50
Average75
Good100
Great
2. Select any tags that apply to this area
View results

Compare Middle Island, NY Livability

City Image
    City Default Image
      vs
      Compare Neighborhoods & Addresses Local Insights Report

      Why stop at city-to-city? With Local Insights, you can compare neighborhoods, zip codes, or even exact addresses. Access 300+ hyperlocal data points—from schools and crime to housing and amenities—to see which area is the better fit.

      Local Insights Report

      F Amenities

      Are there many local amenities in Middle Island? Well, there are not many amenities close to this location.

      Parks

      Learn & Play Children's Garden
      Pine Lake Park
      Pine Lake
      Bartlett Pond Park
      Barlett Pound Playground
      Barlett Pound Playground
      Barlett Pound Park
      Artist Lake Park

      Entertainment

      MovieLand Cinemas

      Food & Drink

      Dunkin'
      Taco Bell
      Subway
      McDonald's
      Millhouse Inn
      Domino's
      McDonald's
      Wendy's

      F Commute

      Is public transit available in Middle Island? Of all people who commute, 2.9% take public transportation in Middle Island.
      Drive to Work
      82%

      5% higher than the US average

      Take Public Transit
      3%

      2% lower than the US average

      Walk to Work
      0%

      3% lower than the US average

      F Cost of Living

      What is the cost of living in Middle Island? The cost of living in Middle Island is 124/100 - which is 6% higher than New York.
      Middle Island
      124

      24% more expensive than average

      New York
      117

      17% more expensive than average

      United States
      100

      National cost of living index

      D+ Crime

      What is the crime rate in Middle Island? Middle Island crime rates are 2,048, which are 6% lower than New York
      Total Crime
      2,048 per 100k people

      10% lower than the US average

      Chance of being a victim
      1 in 49  

      10% lower than the US average

      Year-over-year crime
      -5%

      Year over year crime is down

      A+ Employment

      What is the median income in Middle Island? The median income in Middle Island is $75,545 which is 24% higher than New York.
      Median household income
      $75,54537% higher than the US average
      Income per capita
      $36,81723% higher than the US average
      Unemployment rate
      2%

      47% lower than the US average

      F Health & Safety

      Is Middle Island a healthy and safe place to live? No, there are not many hospitals, police and fire stations,

      Hospitals

      Pharmacies

      Doctors

      A+ Housing

      What are Middle Island home prices? Middle Island home prices are $274,700 - which is 4% lower than New York
      Median home value
      $274,70049% higher than the US average
      Median rent price
      $1,71881% higher than the US average
      Home Ownership
      70%

      11% higher than the US average

      B- Schools

      Does Middle Island have good schools? The Middle Island graduation rate is 89% - which is 9% higher than New York
      High school grad. rates
      89%

      7% higher than the US average

      School test scores
      59%

      24% higher than the US average

      Student teacher ratio
      0:1

      100% lower than the US average

      A+ User Ratings

      Is Middle Island a good place to live? Middle Island has an overall rating of 92% from 4 reviews.
      Overall user rating
      92%

      4 total ratings

      User reviews rating
      90%

      1 total reviews

      User surveys rating
      95%

      3 total surveys

      General
      For Professionals
      Follow Us
      AV on Twitter AV on Facebook
      © AreaVibes Inc. 2010-2025