Above is a snapshot look at the real estate market in Middle Island, NY. In Middle Island, NY, the median house price is $265,000, making the price 7% lower than that the average for New York. Therefore, the affordability of Middle Island, NY area real estate is more affordable than the real estate in other areas of New York. In addition, Middle Island, NY has a median rent price of $1,594; this price is 38% higher than that the average rental price for New York. 76.6% of residents in Middle Island, NY are homeowners, and the average amount of people who reside in each home is 2.4. Middle Island, NY has a wide array of real estate options available, ranging from cost-friendly condos to high-end luxury homes. We filter listings by number of bathrooms and bedrooms, price and area to simplify the search process for Middle Island, NY real estate for sale.