Shelter Island Housing Information - Census

IndexShelter IslandNew YorkNational
Median home price$677,200$283,700$175,700
Median rent asked$1,329$1,117$920
Avg. people per household2.62.62.6
Owner occupied households84.5%53.8%64.4%
Renter occupied households15.5%46.2%35.6%

Shelter Island Housing Information - Zillow

IndexShelter IslandNew YorkNational
Zillow home value indexn/a$267,100$188,100
Year over year appreciation raten/a2.73%5.14%
5 year average appreciation raten/a1.06%4.12%
10 year average appreciation raten/an/a-0.33%

Did you know?

  • The median home price in Shelter Island is 285% higher than the national average.
  • The median rent asked in Shelter Island is 44% higher than the national average.
  • The average number of people per household in Shelter Island is equal to the national average.
  • The number of owner occupied households in Shelter Island is 31% higher than the national average.
  • The number of renter occupied households in Shelter Island is 57% lower than the national average.

Find Real Estate Listings In Shelter Island

Location
Price
Bedrooms
Bathrooms
 

New Real Estate Listings In Shelter Island

See more Shelter Island, NY apartments for rent

Compare Shelter Island, NY Housing To Other Cities

Vacancy vs occupancy levels

Vacancy status breakdown

Household statistics

Heating methods

Rent percent of household income

Inclusion of utilites in rent

Nearby cities with low home prices

City, StatePopulationHome PriceNational Avg.
Dering Harbor, NY5$0100%
Flanders, NY4,851$323,00084%
Jamesport, NY1,573$384,900119%
Hampton Bays, NY12,712$433,500147%
Greenport West, NY1,936$449,300156%
Shelter Island, NY1,270$677,200285%

Cities with similar population

City, StatePopulationHome PriceNational Avg.
St. Paul, TX1,270$248,50041%
Monticello, WI1,270$127,20028%
Elizabeth, CO1,270$177,5001%
Fruitport, MI1,270$109,00038%
Wells, NV1,269$120,80031%
Shelter Island, NY1,270$677,200285%
Source: The Shelter Island, NY housing data displayed above is derived from the United States Census Bureau and Zillow data.