Name: Fire Island, NY
Rating: 0.0

Get 300+ Local Insights for Any Address in Fire Island, NY

Get Access to 300+ Local Data Points

( 2 Ratings )

Living in Fire Island, NY

Ranks better than 61% of areas Follow

Population

368

Median Age

40.0 Years

Fire Island Area Facts

Fire Island has a Livability Score of 61_/100, which is considered average
Fire Island crime rates are 38% lower than the New York average
Cost of living in Fire Island is 22% higher than the New York average

Is This the Right Place for You?

Uncover the key details before you move
Use local data to guide a smarter investment
Compare neighborhoods side by side

GET REPORT →

What do the locals think about Fire Island?

0%

Family friendly

0%

Public transit is accessible

0%

Walkable to grocery stores

0%

Yards are well-kept

0%

Lots of parks

0%

Walkable to restaurants

Friendly neighbors

Safe at night

Pet friendly

Streets have sidewalks

50%

A quiet area

0%

Sense of community

Based on 2 votes from AreaVibes users. Take the poll

Fire Island Reviews

Write a review about Fire Island Tell people what you like or don't like about Fire Island…

Show All Reviews

Compare Fire Island, NY Livability

Compare Neighborhoods & Addresses

Why stop at city-to-city? With Local Insights, you can compare neighborhoods, zip codes, or even exact addresses. Access 300+ hyperlocal data points—from schools and crime to housing and amenities—to see which area is the better fit.

UNLOCK FULL COMPARISON →

F Amenities

Are there many local amenities in Fire Island? Well, there are not many amenities close to this location.

Parks

Entertainment

Cherry Grove Community House and Theatre

Food & Drink

Seaview Liquors

Schooner Inn

Mermaid Market

Ice Castle

The Sandbar

Fire Island Liquor Store

F Commute

Is public transit available in Fire Island? Of all people who commute, 12.4% take public transportation in Fire Island.

Drive to Work

66%

11% lower than the US average

Take Public Transit

12%

7% higher than the US average

Walk to Work

5%

2% higher than the US average

F Cost of Living

What is the cost of living in Fire Island? The cost of living in Fire Island is 143/100 - which is 22% higher than New York.

Fire Island

143

43% more expensive than average

New York

117

17% more expensive than average

United States

100

National cost of living index

B- Crime

What is the crime rate in Fire Island? Fire Island crime rates are 1,367, which are 38% lower than New York

Total Crime

1,367 per 100k people

40% lower than the US average

Chance of being a victim

1 in 74

40% lower than the US average

Year-over-year crime

-12%

Year over year crime is down

A+ Employment

What is the median income in Fire Island? The median income in Fire Island is $100,250 which is 65% higher than New York.

Median household income

$100,25081% higher than the US average

Income per capita

$40,76037% higher than the US average

Unemployment rate

3%

46% lower than the US average

C+ Health & Safety

Is Fire Island a healthy and safe place to live? Yes, there are some hospitals, police and fire stations.

Hospitals

Pharmacies

Doctors

B+ Housing

What are Fire Island home prices? Fire Island home prices are $450,000 - which is 57% higher than New York

Median home value

$450,000144% higher than the US average

Median rent price

$1,40648% higher than the US average

Home Ownership

78%

22% higher than the US average

F Schools

Does Fire Island have good schools? The Fire Island graduation rate is 79% - which is 4% lower than New York

High school grad. rates

79%

5% lower than the US average

School test scores

?

100% lower than the US average

Student teacher ratio

0:1

100% lower than the US average

D User Ratings

Is Fire Island a good place to live? Fire Island has an overall rating of 53% from 2 reviews.

2 total ratings

0 total reviews

2 total surveys

Fire Island, NY Area Guide