Bay Harbor Islands 86 Exceptional
Bay Harbor Islands Livability #15 ranked city in Florida#344 ranked city in the USARanks better than 98% of areas
Is This the Right Place for You? Local Insights Report
  • Uncover the key details before you move
  • Use local data to guide a smarter investment
  • Compare neighborhoods side by side
Local Insights Report

Pros and Cons of Living in Bay Harbor Islands

PROS
  • Commute Commute

    High commute scores indicates that public transit should be easily accessible in this area and the average commute time to work is less than average.

  • Crime Crime

    With a lower than average crime rate per 100,000 people, this area could be considered a very safe place to live. Crime rates are based on both violent and property crimes.

  • Employment Employment

    The combination of higher than average median home income, income per capita and low unemployment rates results in a score that is well above average in the employment category.

  • Housing Housing

    This area has received high scores in the housing category. This could be due to a positive home affordability ratio, high appreciation rates or elevated home values.

  • Health & Safety Health & Safety

    A high score in the health and safety category is a result of good air quality and the accessibility to health facilities such as hospitals, clinics, doctors, pharmacies and fire stations.

CONS
  • Amenities Amenities

    A majority of amenities are not ideally situated within a reasonable walking distance, which may lead residents to rely on a vehicle or public transportation.

  • Cost Of Living Cost Of Living

    Based on the most recent cost of living data, this area is more expensive to live in. You can expect to pay more for everyday goods and services, housing, groceries and utilities.

What's it like Living in Bay Harbor Islands?

Located in the state of Florida, Bay Harbor Islands is a smaller city with a population of 6,061 people. With a population density of 15,291 people per square mile, Bay Harbor Islands is well above the nation's average density level. According to the most recent Census, 71% of Bay Harbor Islands residents are White, 4% Black and 1% Asian. Additionally, more than a quarter of the population of Bay Harbor Islands are of Hispanic or Latino origin, and 54% of the population also speak Spanish. Long, unnecessary commutes can be both frustrating and inconvenient when heading to work. Nationwide, the average one-way commute time takes 26 minutes, but regrettably, residing in Bay Harbor Islands entails a longer-than-average one-way commute time, averaging 30 minutes.

Without the right tools, moving to any new town can be very stressful and challenging. Living in Bay Harbor Islands, Florida could be a positive experience for anyone who puts in the effort to do the research required. When searching for a new neighborhood, several key items should be considered. Safety is paramount, ensuring a secure environment for you and your family. Proximity to workplaces or schools reduces commuting time and enhances convenience. Access to amenities like parks, grocery stores and healthcare facilities contributes to a comfortable lifestyle. Reliable public transportation options promote easy mobility. A strong sense of community fosters social connections and a welcoming atmosphere. To help you find the best places to live in and around Bay Harbor Islands, AreaVibes has created a livability score using key metrics like commute, health & safety, housing and more.

The livability score in Bay Harbor Islands is 87/100 and the city is ranked in the 99th percentile of all cities across America. This is a great score, as Bay Harbor Islands ranks well in multiple categories! The cherry on top is that Bay Harbor Islands also ranks in the top 10 percent of all cities. If we examine each of the categories individually, we see that Bay Harbor Islands ranks well for crime (A+), education (A+) and housing (A+). Bay Harbor Islands does not score well for the following: amenities (F) and cost of living (F). It might be a smart idea to take a closer look at each category to find out why.

Crime rates play a pivotal role in the decision-making process for anyone considering a move, as they directly influence the overall sense of safety, security and quality of life in a given location. Bay Harbor Islands shines in this regard, earning exemplary ratings for its exceptionally low violent crime rates, standing at 36 crimes per 100,000 residents. These rates are notably below the national average, underscoring the community's commitment to safety and contributing to an enhanced quality of life.

Test scores can be a good way to measure a school's academic performance and the proficiency of its students. They can be an important metric in deciding if the local area schools can provide a solid educational system for children. The schools in Bay Harbor Islands have an average test score of 81%, which is well above the US average.

Real estate represents the most substantial investment for homebuyers, constituting their most valuable asset. Renters, on the other hand, typically see their monthly rent as their most significant expense. The Bay Harbor Islands market earns a high score in the housing category, surpassing the national average in factors like home and rental affordability and appreciation rates. This robust real estate market not only benefits individual homeowners and renters but also spurs vigorous local economic activity and job growth, solidifying its significance in driving the region's prosperity and financial well-being.

Certain items on your wish list like shopping, restaurants, nightlife, parks and proximity to public transportation are all important things to look for. Having said that, perhaps the most important metric to consider when contemplating a move to Bay Harbor Islands is real estate affordability. The median home price for Bay Harbor Islands homes is $826,226, which is 175.8% higher than the Florida average. If we take a closer look at the affordability of homes in Bay Harbor Islands, we’ll see that the home price to income ratio is 5.7, which is 35.7% higher than the Florida average.

Best Places to Live in and Around Bay Harbor Islands

See all the best places to live around Bay Harbor Islands

How Do You Rate The Livability In Bay Harbor Islands?

1. Select a livability score between 1-100
0
Awful
25
Poor
50
Average
75
Good
100
Great
2. Select any tags that apply to this area
View results

Compare Bay Harbor Islands, FL Livability

City Image
    City Default Image
      vs
      Compare Neighborhoods & Addresses Local Insights Report

      Why stop at city-to-city? With Local Insights, you can compare neighborhoods, zip codes, or even exact addresses. Access 300+ hyperlocal data points—from schools and crime to housing and amenities—to see which area is the better fit.

      Local Insights Report

      Bay Harbor Islands transportation information

      Statistic Bay Harbor Islands Florida National
      Average one way commute30min27min26min
      Workers who drive to work63.2%79.5%76.4%
      Workers who carpool10.2%9.3%9.3%
      Workers who take public transit4.5%2.1%5.1%
      Workers who bicycle0.0%0.7%0.6%
      Workers who walk2.9%1.5%2.8%
      Working from home12.4%5.4%4.6%
      Source: The Bay Harbor Islands, FL data and statistics displayed above are derived from the United States Census Bureau American Community Survey (ACS) and include 2026 modeled data developed using proprietary methodologies.