Fayetteville 83 Exceptional
Fayetteville Livability #63 ranked city in New York#874 ranked city in the USARanks better than 97% of areas
Is This the Right Place for You? Local Insights Report
  • Uncover the key details before you move
  • Use local data to guide a smarter investment
  • Compare neighborhoods side by side
Local Insights Report

Pros and Cons of Living in Fayetteville

PROS
  • Crime Crime

    The crime rate is far lower than the national average per 100,000 residents. As such, it should be considered a very safe place to live when compared to other areas.

  • Employment Employment

    This area excels in the employment category with a score well above average, primarily due to the higher median home income, per capita income and low unemployment rates.

  • Housing Housing

    High scores in the housing category are attributed to this area, possibly pointing to a favorable home affordability ratio, robust appreciation rates or elevated home values.

  • Health & Safety Health & Safety

    Achieving a high health and safety score relies on factors including great air quality and convenient access to vital health facilities such as hospitals, doctors, clinics and police stations.

  • Schools Schools

    The schools category boasts a high score thanks to factors like excellent test scores, impressive graduation rates and the convenient placement of elementary and high schools in this area.

CONS
  • Commute Commute

    Access to public transportation in this particular area may be limited, which can result in longer-than-average commute times to reach workplaces.

What's it like Living in Fayetteville?

Fayetteville, New York is a small-sized city with a population of 4,157 residents. At 91%, the majority of the Fayetteville population is White; this is followed by 2% Asian and 1% Black. Based on an average age of 49, Fayetteville appears to be well-suited for seniors or retirees as the average age is well above the national average. The average American spends about 26 minutes on their one way commute to work each day. Lower travel times can increase overall happiness and allow for more time to be spent with family and friends. While living in Fayetteville, your commute times will be about average, with a one way commute time of 23 minutes.

Without the right tools, moving to any new town can be very stressful and challenging. Living in Fayetteville, New York could be a good experience for anyone who puts in the effort to do the research required. When searching for a new neighborhood, several key items should be considered. Safety is paramount, ensuring a secure environment for you and your family. Proximity to workplaces or schools reduces commuting time and enhances convenience. Access to amenities like parks, grocery stores and healthcare facilities contributes to a comfortable lifestyle. Reliable public transportation options promote easy mobility. A strong sense of community fosters social connections and a welcoming atmosphere. Finding the best places to live in Fayetteville and nearby areas is a much easier task when you can rely on information and data from the livability score, which includes crime, cost of living, housing and other important metrics.

Using data and statistics Fayetteville has received a livability score of 81/100. This score is ranked in the 95th percentile when compared to all other cities. This is a great score, as Fayetteville ranks well in multiple categories! The cherry on top is that Fayetteville also ranks in the top 10 percent of all cities. Based on the grades for each individual category, Fayetteville has received high marks for crime (B) and education (A+). Regrettably for Fayetteville, there are some categories for which it does not score well, this includes: amenities (D) and cost of living (D).

The unemployment rate in Fayetteville has consistently declined over the years and currently stands well below the national average at 2.2%. This downward trend holds the potential to reduce poverty and inequality within the region, promote higher wage levels and stimulate greater economic growth. Such positive indicators signal the overall robust health of the local economy, offering a promising outlook for its residents and fostering an environment of financial well-being and prosperity.

Parents and families tend to prioritize school test scores when choosing educational institutions. Test score data can be a critical factor in evaluating and comparing schools. In Fayetteville, the average school test scores are an impressive 74%, well above the national average. This achievement reflects the educational system's dedication to providing students with the essential knowledge and tools for success. It ensures that your children will receive the support and resources needed to excel academically and thrive in their educational pursuits.

Real estate represents the most substantial investment for homebuyers, constituting their most valuable asset. Renters, on the other hand, typically see their monthly rent as their most significant expense. The Fayetteville market earns a high score in the housing category, surpassing the national average in factors like home and rental affordability and appreciation rates. This robust real estate market not only benefits individual homeowners and renters but also spurs vigorous local economic activity and job growth, solidifying its significance in driving the region's prosperity and financial well-being.

Assuming that Fayetteville meets all of your requirements like low crime rates, good schools and great local amenities, the next most important item to examine is the affordability of real estate in Fayetteville. Everything else becomes a lot less important if it turns out that home prices in Fayetteville are simply unattainable. Median real estate prices in Fayetteville come in at $362,420, which is 28% lower than the New York average. The home price to income ratio compares the median home prices to the median household income. In Fayetteville, the home price to income ratio is 2.3, which is 58.9% lower than the New York average.

Best Places to Live in and Around Fayetteville

See all the best places to live around Fayetteville

How Do You Rate The Livability In Fayetteville?

1. Select a livability score between 1-100
0
Awful
25
Poor
50
Average
75
Good
100
Great
2. Select any tags that apply to this area
View results

Compare Fayetteville, NY Livability

City Image
    City Default Image
      vs
      Compare Neighborhoods & Addresses Local Insights Report

      Why stop at city-to-city? With Local Insights, you can compare neighborhoods, zip codes, or even exact addresses. Access 300+ hyperlocal data points—from schools and crime to housing and amenities—to see which area is the better fit.

      Local Insights Report

      Fayetteville transportation information

      Statistic Fayetteville New York National
      Average one way commute23min33min26min
      Workers who drive to work82.2%53.0%76.4%
      Workers who carpool4.9%6.7%9.3%
      Workers who take public transit1.4%28.0%5.1%
      Workers who bicycle0.0%0.7%0.6%
      Workers who walk1.6%6.3%2.8%
      Working from home8.1%4.0%4.6%
      Source: The Fayetteville, NY data and statistics displayed above are derived from the United States Census Bureau American Community Survey (ACS) and include 2026 modeled data developed using proprietary methodologies.