Above, you'll find an overview of the real estate market in Oyster Bay, NY. Generally, real estate in the Oyster Bay, NY area is less affordable in New York, as the median price of a home in Oyster Bay, NY is $556,400, which is 94% higher than the New York average. The median rental price in Oyster Bay, NY is $1,860. This is 60% higher than the average rental price in New York. Home owners comprise 61.4% of the population of Oyster Bay, NY, where an average of 2.3 people live in each home. Various real estate options from luxurious homes to affordable condos and urban townhomes are available in Oyster Bay, NY. Below, you can search for real estate listings in Oyster Bay, NY using our search functionality that allows you to personalize your search and filter out location, price, and number of bedrooms and bathrooms.