A general overview of the Carthage, NY real estate market is displayed above. The median home price for homes in Carthage, NY is $134,200, which is 53% lower than the New York average. This means that real estate in the Carthage, NY area is generally more affordable than the rest of New York. The median rent price in Carthage, NY is $915 which is 21% lower than the New York average. In Carthage, NY, 45.1% of people are home owners and an average of 2.8 people occupy each home. From luxury houses to affordable condos to urban townhomes, there are many different types of real estate in Carthage, NY. We make it easy to find Carthage, NY real estate listings and homes for sale by filtering location, price, bedrooms and bathrooms in the search area above.