| Index | Bay Shore | New York | National |
| Median home price | $309,100 | $286,300 | $184,700 |
| Median rent asked | $1,384 | $1,159 | $949 |
| Avg. people per household | 3.1 | 2.6 | 2.6 |
| Owner occupied households | 58.9% | 53.6% | 63.6% |
| Renter occupied households | 41.1% | 46.4% | 36.4% |
| Index | Bay Shore | New York | National |
| Zillow home value index | n/a | $287,600 | $196,500 |
| Year over year appreciation rate | n/a | 8.16% | 6.79% |
| 5 year average appreciation rate | n/a | 3.26% | 5.28% |
| 10 year average appreciation rate | n/a | n/a | 0.01% |
| City, State | Population | Home Price | National Avg. |
| Wyandanch, NY | 10,722 | $238,000 | 29% |
| Central Islip, NY | 34,724 | $252,700 | 37% |
| North Amityville, NY | 20,150 | $271,800 | 47% |
| Brentwood, NY | 61,438 | $280,800 | 52% |
| Baywood, NY | 7,415 | $281,600 | 52% |
| Bay Shore, NY | 29,704 | $309,100 | 67% |
| City, State | Population | Home Price | National Avg. |
| Prairieville, LA | 29,732 | $220,700 | 19% |
| Granite City, IL | 29,662 | $83,700 | 55% |
| Mehlville, MO | 29,749 | $150,000 | 19% |
| Oak Park, MI | 29,751 | $82,500 | 55% |
| Cleburne, TX | 29,759 | $95,500 | 48% |
| Bay Shore, NY | 29,704 | $309,100 | 67% |