| Index | Bay Shore | New York | National |
| Median home price | $318,000 | $283,700 | $175,700 |
| Median rent asked | $1,352 | $1,117 | $920 |
| Avg. people per household | 2.9 | 2.6 | 2.6 |
| Owner occupied households | 56.8% | 53.8% | 64.4% |
| Renter occupied households | 43.2% | 46.2% | 35.6% |
| Index | Bay Shore | New York | National |
| Zillow home value index | n/a | $287,600 | $196,500 |
| Year over year appreciation rate | n/a | 8.16% | 6.79% |
| 5 year average appreciation rate | n/a | 3.26% | 5.28% |
| 10 year average appreciation rate | n/a | n/a | 0.01% |
| City, State | Population | Home Price | National Avg. |
| Wyandanch, NY | 11,187 | $251,900 | 43% |
| Central Islip, NY | 36,233 | $259,000 | 47% |
| Brentwood, NY | 59,436 | $278,500 | 59% |
| North Amityville, NY | 19,608 | $279,700 | 59% |
| North Bay Shore, NY | 19,995 | $281,900 | 60% |
| Bay Shore, NY | 28,883 | $318,000 | 81% |
| City, State | Population | Home Price | National Avg. |
| Wellesley, MA | 28,858 | $914,000 | 420% |
| Golden Gate, FL | 28,917 | $129,200 | 26% |
| East Palo Alto, CA | 28,920 | $386,100 | 120% |
| Norwood, MA | 28,844 | $376,800 | 114% |
| Perry Hall, MD | 28,924 | $250,700 | 43% |
| Bay Shore, NY | 28,883 | $318,000 | 81% |